Since 2004, this West Village institution has been serving classic cocktails by bartenders in white pharmacy jackets, creating a timeless atmosphere that feels like stepping into a 1920s apothecary. The long bar encourages interaction between strangers, and the late-night kitchen serves food until 3:30am, making it a magnet for industry workers and night owls. The space has a lived-in warmth, with dim lighting and a soundtrack that encourages conversation rather than shouting.

This is why it made the JUICY list: the bar seating layout naturally facilitates conversation between neighbors, and the late-night hours create a sense of intimacy among the people who are still out when the rest of the city has gone to bed, fostering a community of night dwellers.